The Broker

Corruption in Afghanistan, or the hypocrisy of international politics

Thea Hilhorst | 08 November 2009

I have always known that politics are hypocritical, but sometimes it gets to me nonetheless. I am in New York at the moment, where I spend eight weeks of my sabbatical as guest-lecturer at Columbia University. This week, after it became clear that president Karzai of Afghanistan was going to be president for an other term, President Obama phoned him and told reporters afterwards that he told him “to move boldly and forcefully forward and take advantage of the international community’s interest in his country to initiate reforms internally”. The US administration wants Afghanistan to form an anti-corruption commission and arrest the more blatantly corrupt people in the government.

The first person who comes to mind would no doubt be the brother of President Karzai. Ahmed Wali Karzai is notorious for his alleged ties to drugstrade and his kinship relation to the president has been a prominent and symbolic marker of the Afghan’s government lack of determination to combat corruption.

The phone call of Obama to Karzai took place on 3 November. On 28 October, just 6 days earlier, the New York Times featured on its frontpage that the CIA has Ahmed Wali Karzai on its payroll, apparently to finance warlord-related militia. Can politics get any more surreal?

Comments

Your comment will not be automatically posted but first reviewed by the editor. If the editor has questions with respect to the content of your comment, you will be contacted.

 

response

Thanks for the suggestion, I am going to get the book. As for the question of Frans, I would think the answer lies in the response of the international community to the Afghan government. As NATO Sec-Gen Jaap de Hoop Scheffer stated in the Washongton Post of 18 January 2009: The basic problem of Afganistan is not too much Taliban, but too little good governance.
Thea Hilhorst | November 13, 2009 | Respond

Corruption in Afghanistan

There is a good book I just read about corruption in Afghanistan. It's called Turbulence.....think the website is www.turbulencethebook.com. The author Nadir Atash witnessed firsthand systematic corruption in the government and it's not as black and white as you would think. It's a mafia network and I'm not convinced it is just Afghans who are behind it. I was shocked after reading this book what can happen to someone if they try to after the bad guys in Afghanistan.
Shai | November 12, 2009 | Respond

consequences for other countries?

I totally agree, Thea. And what does that mean for the involvement of other countries in Afghanistan, like, for example, the Netherlands?
Frans Bieckmann | November 08, 2009 | Respond